Counterpossible Reasoning in Philosophy of Religion (and Elsewhere)
The latest (July 2011) Faith and Philosophy contains an excellent article by Jeff Speaks on some difficulties related to establishing the consistency of certain claims (he uses as examples the existence of human freedom and the existence of evil) with the existence of an Anselmian God. The basic idea is this: since an Anselmian God is, by definition, a necessary being, establishing the possibility of an Anselmian God is tantamount to establishing the necessary, and therefore actual, existence of an Anselmian God. But these compatibility arguments typically, in one way or another, assume the possibility, and so the actuality, of...
Continue reading "Counterpossible Reasoning in Philosophy of Religion (and Elsewhere)"
Topic(s):
Alvin Plantinga
,
Conditionals
,
Contemporary Thinkers
,
Jeff Speaks
,
Logic
,
Metaphysics
,
Modality
,
Philosophy
,
Philosophy of Religion
,
Ted A. Warfield
,
The Problem of Evil
,
Trenton Merricks
Posted by
Kenny at
12:51 PM
|
Comments (0)
|
TrackBack (0)