Would a Being With All Positive Properties Be God?
Sobel's final objection to ontological arguments is that, even if they are sound, their conclusion does not mean that God exists. That is, according to Sobel, a necessarily existing 'being than which none greater can be conceived' or 'being with all perfections' or 'being with all positive properties' would not be God. His argument for this is rather confusing and depends (1) on a controversial modal intuition, and (2) on an odd definition of 'worshipfulness'. As far as I can tell, the argument goes like this: it is clear (so Sobel claims) that such properties as consciousness, knowledge, power, love,...
Continue reading "Would a Being With All Positive Properties Be God?"
Topic(s):
'Worshipfulness'
,
Contemporary Thinkers
,
Existence of God
,
Historical Thinkers
,
J. N. Findlay
,
Jordan Howard Sobel
,
Kurt Gödel
,
Ontological Argument
,
Philosophy
,
Philosophy of Religion
,
Plato
Posted by
Kenny at
9:15 PM
|
Comments (0)
|
TrackBack (0)